Katie has lost her faith in God. She cannot fathom why her parents disappeared in the forest during a winter storm and were never found again. Seeking financial solace, she decides to become a mail order bride. A wealthy farmer becomes smitten with her description and proposes marriage. But it turns out that her new farmer husband has a horrific secret that he tries hard to keep away from her. Will Katie be able to forgive him and allow their new romance to blossom into something they both want?