When teenage son Michael is being accused of murdering his girlfriend, the well-respected and close-knit Amish family is in turmoil. Michael flees, father Caleb destroys possible evidence, the village community turns hostile and mother Mary is forced to temporarily close her family business. Then Michael gets arrested and soon finds himself and his family entangled in a web of truth, trust and lies, all on his way to court...But did Michael really do it?